I’ve been a cautiously optimistic fanboy this week, due to the news that Neil Gaiman’s American Gods is in development as a series. American Gods is one of my all-time favorite novels, and I’m curious to see how it translates to the screen — even more so after reading that Neil has asked the producers not to whitewash any of his characters of color.
That got me to thinking about the diversity of the Action Figures cast of characters, and whether I was doing a good job of representing a variety of genders, sexual orientations and identities, and races. As a bit of an internal exercise, I went through the main and prominent secondary characters and tagged them, and here’s the result:
- Carrie/Lightstorm: white female
- Matt/Captain Trenchcoat: white male
- Sara/Psyche: white female
- Stuart/Superbeast: male, quarter African-American
- Missy/Kunoichi: female, half-Japanese
- Concorde: male
- Mindforce: white male
- Nina Nitro: Hispanic female
- Dr. Enigma: white female, bisexual
- Joe Quentin/Rockjaw Quantum: male
- Gwendolyn Quentin/Doc Quantum: female
- Meg Quentin/Megawatt Quantum: white female
- Kilroy Quentin/Kilowatt Quantum: white male
- Farley Quentin/Final Boss: white male
You’ll notice that only one character, Dr. Enigma, has a distinct sexual orientation. Three other people on the list are homo- or bi-sexual, but their respective reveals are tied to story and forthcoming (if not in book three, definitely in book four).
You’ll also notice that the cast is primarily white. Eight characters are explicitly described as white, nine if you assume at least Rockjaw or Doc Quantum are white (which is a natural assumption, considering the kids are described as pale-skinned with very light blond hair).
If I start adding prominent tertiary cast members (the kids’ parents, recurring supporting characters), things don’t necessarily get more colorful, so to speak. Missy has a Japanese father, Stuart has one half-African-American parent, but the rest of the parents are white (implicitly if not explicitly). Much of the supporting cast is of unspecified ethnicity, which can be good or bad; readers can fill in the blanks and assume these characters are people of color if they like, but I could also take a bolder stance and say “Character A is a person of color.”
My concern with establishing as canon that a character is someone of color is that it would wind up as little more than paying lip service to diversity. I realize it could be argued that simply having a person of color present is enough, that it makes them a presence in the story, but I want the character’s ethnicity to matter, to the character or the story, and not become a throwaway element — but, as the writer, it’s incumbent on me to do just that, isn’t it?
I am pleased with the gender balance. Of the above-listed characters, half are women, and two are in leadership roles (Carrie and Doc Quantum). Additionally, the male characters are portrayed as comfortable with that, and I’d like to think that sends a good message all around.
If I were to give myself a grade for diversity in my novels, I’d give myself a solid B-minus, at best. I could definitely do better, and hope to as the series progresses.
2 thoughts on “The Action Figures Diversity Report”
It’s very cool that you’re willing to check yourself on this—plenty of (white) authors never bother. I’d throw in that disability is another category to consider—it’s one that’s almost universally overlooked, but when you’re writing superheroes, it’s also unusually easy to handle (which is why you get classic characters like Daredevil and Professor X).
I admit, it’s tough for me to think about such things instinctively. I find I too often start writing white characters by default, even if their race is only in my head rather than on the page, and only later in the process do I ask whether a character can and should be done differently. I’m trying to train myself to think outside the white box, which is part of what sparked this little exercise.